Make vs n8n vs Zapier: An Honest Comparison for 2026
Over the last two years, we have delivered more than 40 automation projects with Make.com, n8n and Zapier. Here is what really works, and where each tool hits its limits.
Choosing an automation platform is one of the most expensive tech decisions you will make in the next three years. Not because of the monthly subscription, but because of the hidden costs: migration effort, lock-in, performance limits as you grow, and the question of whether your data is even allowed to stay in the EU.
At Cogswell IT, we work with all three platforms every day. Make.com for visual workflows of medium complexity. n8n for GDPR-critical setups on your own server. Zapier when speed comes before everything else. This article is not an advertisement. It is the unfiltered version of what we tell clients in workshops.
If you are looking for a clear “Tool X wins” verdict, you won't find it here. What you get instead: a comparison table, five concrete scenarios from German mid-sized businesses and honest statements about when switching hurts.
Comparison table: the hard facts
So you get an overview right away, here are the key figures as of May 2026:
| Criterion | Zapier | Make.com | n8n |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing (entry level) | from approx. €20/month | from approx. €9/month | Cloud from approx. €20/month, self-hosted free |
| Pricing (10k ops/month) | approx. €70 to €100/month | approx. €20 to €30/month | approx. €50/month or self-hosted |
| Self-hosting | No | No | Yes, fully open source |
| EU hosting | No (US only) | Yes (EU region selectable) | Yes, or your own server |
| Number of apps | 7,000+ integrations | 2,000+ integrations | 500+ nodes, plus HTTP for everything |
| Learning curve | Low (1 to 2 days) | Medium (1 week) | High (2 to 4 weeks) |
| Code possible | JavaScript/Python (Pro) | JavaScript functions | JavaScript & Python natively |
| GDPR suitability | Limited | Solid with EU hosting | Maximum (when self-hosted) |
The table is a starting point, not a verdict. Which number really counts depends on how you use the tool. Below, we break down each tool and tell you when it is worth it.
Zapier: the market leader with weaknesses
Zapier has been the top dog for years, and it shows. More than 7,000 integrations, a relentlessly simple UI and templates for practically every standard use case. If you want to go from “never automated anything” to “it's running” in an hour, Zapier is the shortest route.
Where Zapier really shines
- A fast start without a tech background. A bookkeeper who wants to pull invoices from Outlook into a Google Sheet is done in 20 minutes with Zapier.
- Niche apps that don't work anywhere else. We have had clients with specialized tools (for example, American practice management systems) that only Zapier could connect.
- Stability. Zapier zaps have been running for years without maintenance. Not every tool can say that.
Where Zapier really hurts
- Pricing scales brutally. From 10,000 operations per month, it gets expensive. We know clients who pay €400+ a month and only don't switch because the migration effort would be higher.
- No self-hosting. Your data runs through US servers. For many mid-sized businesses in regulated industries, that is a no-go.
- “Billed per task” is confusing. A workflow with three steps counts three times. That pushes the calculation up surprisingly often.
- Complex workflows get messy. From 10 steps on, the linear view loses the overview.
Make.com: the visual middle ground
Make (formerly Integromat) is our standard for clients who need more than simple workflows but don't want to run their own server infrastructure. Once you get used to it, the node-based UI is faster than any linear editor. And compared to Zapier, the pricing is almost unfairly cheap.
Where Make really shines
- Visual workflows with branches. If you want to send data to three systems in parallel, with conditions and error handling, Make shows it on a canvas you will still understand three months later.
- Fair pricing at medium volume. 10,000 operations in Make cost only a fraction of what they cost in Zapier. That makes it the sweet spot for SMEs.
- EU hosting available. Since 2024, Make has offered dedicated EU regions, GDPR-compliant and with a data processing agreement (DPA).
- The HTTP modules are excellent. APIs that Make doesn't support natively can be connected in 10 minutes with the generic HTTP module.
Where Make falls short
- Performance with large workflows. Scenarios with 30+ modules get sluggish. We have had setups that took 90 seconds per run, which becomes a problem at 1,000 runs a day.
- Debugging is annoying. Finding errors in deeply nested iterators takes time. The logs are okay, but not great.
- “Operations” are not intuitive. An iterator counts every loop as an operation, which can blow up the pricing model.
- Self-hosting is missing entirely. If you have to keep data on-premise for legal reasons, you are out.
n8n: the choice for pros and privacy advocates
n8n is what we recommend when someone says “GDPR” or “our own server”. Open source, self-hostable, with real code support. But be honest with yourself: n8n is not a tool for someone who has never seen a console.
Where n8n really shines
- Self-hosting is real and free. A Docker container on your Hetzner server, done. No operation limits, no user limits, no lock-in worries.
- Maximum GDPR protection. If your data never leaves your data center, the legal situation is trivial. That is worth its weight in gold for industries like healthcare, law or finance.
- Code-first philosophy. JavaScript and Python nodes natively. Complex logic that would need four modules in Make or Zapier is a single function in n8n.
- Versioning via Git. Export workflows as JSON, commit them to Git, review them as a team. The other tools simply can't do that.
Where n8n really hurts
- Learning curve. Plan two to four weeks until a team is productive. The documentation is good, but the concepts (items, loops, expressions) take getting used to.
- Maintaining the self-hosted setup. Updates, backups, monitoring: all of that is your responsibility. If the server goes down at night, nothing runs.
- Fewer out-of-the-box integrations. 500+ nodes sounds like a lot, but it's a fraction of Zapier's. You have to build a lot yourself via HTTP requests.
- UI polish. n8n has caught up, but Make.com feels more refined. A small point, but noticeable in daily use.
Which tool when? Five scenarios from mid-sized businesses
Here's where it gets concrete. We see these five situations regularly at Cogswell IT, and this is how we decide.
Scenario 1: Solo self-employed, 5 workflows, in a hurry
Recommendation: Zapier. If you want to start fast and can't invest 100 hours in a learning curve, Zapier is your best bet. At low volume the pricing is okay, and the templates save you days.
Scenario 2: Mid-sized business with 20 to 50 workflows, EU GDPR obligation
Recommendation: Make.com (EU region). This is the sweet spot: fair pricing, EU hosting, visual UI, DPA available. We use it with about 60% of our clients.
Scenario 3: Tax firm, medical practice, law firm: data must not leave the company
Recommendation: n8n self-hosted. Clear case. Data stays on-premise, no US cloud providers, no DPA drama. More effort at the start, but legally relaxed.
Scenario 4: High volume, 100,000+ operations per month
Recommendation: n8n self-hosted. At this volume, Zapier becomes a monthly mortgage and Make gets sluggish. Self-hosted n8n on a €20 server handles six-figure volumes without a problem.
Scenario 5: Agency, 30 clients, each with their own workflow
Recommendation: Make.com. Multi-workspace management, good user handling, clean pricing per client. n8n is also conceivable here, but client onboarding is faster with Make.
Migration costs: how hard is switching?
Honest answer: harder than you think. We have migrated clients several times, usually from Zapier to Make or n8n. The logic carries over, but every tool has its quirks.
Effort per workflow: For a workflow of medium complexity (10 to 15 steps), plan 4 to 8 hours. That covers rebuilding, testing, edge cases, setting up new authentication and configuring monitoring.
Hidden costs: Data formats don't transfer 1:1. Zapier handles webhooks differently from Make. n8n has its own expression syntax. If you plan a 1:1 migration over a weekend, you will be disappointed.
Our suggestion: Migrate in waves. First the most critical 20% of workflows, run them in parallel, compare, then do the rest. That spreads the risk and gives the team time to learn the new tool.
What really matters to us
When we advise clients, individual features rarely make the difference. Three questions usually decide it:
- Where is your data allowed to live? That is the non-negotiable requirement. If EU hosting or self-hosting is mandatory, Zapier is out.
- Who looks after the tool day to day? Does your team have a tech-savvy person who can maintain a Linux server? If not, n8n becomes a burden.
- How high will your volume be in 12 months? Pricing shock always hits when automations suddenly work and everyone wants more. Plan for three times your current needs.
None of the three tools is objectively the best. They solve different problems. Anyone who tells you otherwise wants to sell you something.
FAQ
Can I use Make.com in a GDPR-compliant way?
Yes, if you choose the EU region and sign a DPA with Make. Make officially offers this. Still, if your industry processes particularly sensitive data (healthcare, law), self-hosted n8n is the safer choice, because the data then never touches an external server.
Is n8n Cloud worth it, or should I go straight to self-hosting?
For beginners, n8n Cloud is worth it to get to know the platform without setting up a server. If you want to scale seriously, switch to self-hosting after 3 to 6 months. A €20 server at Hetzner or IONOS is more than enough for most mid-sized businesses.
We have 50 Zapier workflows. How do we plan a migration?
Take inventory first: which workflows are critical, which are dead? In our experience, 30% of the workflows in old setups are inactive or redundant. Then prioritize and migrate in waves, not all at once. Plan 3 to 6 months for 50 workflows, depending on complexity.
Not sure which tool fits your setup?
30-minute intro call. We give you an honest recommendation, even if it goes against our own tech stack.
Request tool advice →